Breeder snapshot
Dog breeder in Penn Yan, NY. 39 dogs at last count. USDA and New York inspectors cited 24 problems across 27 reports. Every report is free to read.
Penn Yan, New York
Dog breeder in Penn Yan, NY. 39 dogs at last count. USDA and New York inspectors cited 24 problems across 27 reports. Every report is free to read.
John D Shirk – Penn Yan, NY is linked to 27 public inspection reports, carrying 24 inspector findings, from April 2014 to June 2026.
Across 25 inspections between April 2014 and June 2026, inspectors recorded between 16 dogs and 45 dogs at John D Shirk – Penn Yan, NY. The most recent count was 39 dogs on June 11, 2026.
| Date | Licence | Type | Dogs counted | Inspector findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| April 23, 2014 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 17 dogs | 1 finding |
| May 1, 2014 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 16 dogs | None |
| April 30, 2015 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 24 dogs | 1 finding |
| June 9, 2015 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 22 dogs | None |
| May 3, 2016 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 30 dogs | None |
| July 19, 2016 | USDA 21-A-0182 | Inspection | 31 dogs | None |
| April 6, 2017 | USDA 21-A-0182 | Routine inspection | 31 dogs | None |
| May 2, 2017 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 34 dogs | None |
| April 24, 2018 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 41 dogs | 3 findings |
| May 16, 2018 | USDA 21-A-0182 | Routine inspection | 35 dogs | 3 findings |
| May 22, 2018 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 45 dogs | None |
| April 25, 2019 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 35 dogs | None |
| June 4, 2019 | USDA 21-A-0182 | Routine inspection | 40 dogs | 1 finding |
| May 27, 2020 | New York 953 | Attempted inspection | No access | None |
| June 10, 2020 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 30 dogs | None |
| July 3, 2020 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 24 dogs | None |
| July 7, 2021 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 36 dogs | 8 findings |
| August 5, 2021 | New York 953 | Attempted inspection | No access | None |
| September 20, 2021 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 26 dogs | None |
| May 9, 2022 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 30 dogs | 2 findings |
| June 9, 2022 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 27 dogs | None |
| April 11, 2023 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 25 dogs | 4 findings |
| May 4, 2023 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 22 dogs | None |
| May 2, 2024 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 32 dogs | 1 finding |
| May 13, 2024 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 31 dogs | None |
| July 14, 2025 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 30 dogs | None |
| June 11, 2026 | New York 953 | Routine inspection | 39 dogs | None |
17 dogs recorded (15 adults · 2 puppies).
Three Bulldogs without proof of current rabies vaccination
24 dogs recorded (20 adults · 4 puppies).
Lower shelf of whelping boxes which are located under rubber mat/wire flooring have collected dirt and debris.
41 dogs recorded (28 adults · 13 puppies).
Three cages in kennel building had a fine layer of dried fecal dust on floor. A one cage structure had three areas of feces on the wire flooring and the inside area was dirty throughout- no dog had been housed in this cage for several days
Two dogs purchased from out of state without certificates of veterinary inspection.
Treatments given to two Boston Terriers were not stated on the standard form
35 dogs recorded (26 adults · 9 puppies).
General housekeeping needs to be addressed at the facility. Upon entering the building there was a strong ammonia odor attributed to puppy enclosures that were empty but had not been cleaned and still had fecal waste in the pans. This odor permeated into the whelping area as well.
There were boxes of items including microchips with needles stored on top of the enclosures.
An empty feed bag was used as a trash container and per 3.1(f) this receptacle must be leak proof with a tightly fitting lid. The facility is in the process of working on the outdoor runs, but left over items are on the ground next to the enclosures and need to be disposed of. Housekeeping needs to be addressed to keep the area free of accumulations of trash and reduce odors for the health of the animals. Correct by: May 20, 2018
40 dogs recorded (25 adults · 15 puppies).
In a litter of five bulldog puppies, one puppy is very small and is not thriving. The licensee was tube feeding the puppy for an extended period of time during the day but stopped several days ago. The puppy appears to be declining and its condition should be communicated to the attending veterinarian in a timely manner. Correct by: June 7, 2019
36 dogs recorded (21 adults · 15 puppies).
Vet plan lacks meds with doses and current vet signature.
one male dog with intermitten cherry eye missing documenation of vet consult/exam
At least 5 dogs have long nails
2 dogs missing proof of veterinary exam before sale.
Most information statements missing unique IDs
At least 1 receipt missing consumer signature
At least 3 statements missing veterinary heath exam findings, at least 1 statement not signed by consumer.
At least 6 registry disclosures missing consumer signture
30 dogs recorded (22 adults · 8 puppies).
Health exam findings not noted on information statement for puppies 21-12, 21-14, 21-02, 21-03, and 21-06.
Puppy ID on health exam missing for puppy 15-21.
25 dogs recorded (21 adults · 4 puppies).
Male Boston/Cavailer mix "Robert" DOB 8/31/22 sold without proof of valid rabies.
Male Boston terrier " Henry Joe" DOB 12/28/15 not provided with the veterinary care protocol in accordance to veterinary plan for health concern and weight loss.
Condition of Male Boston terrier " Henry Joe" DOB 12/28/15 not observed and/or addressed.
All dogs over 4 monhts of age missing proof of valid license except for except " Janey", " Jeanie", "Ruby", " Champ", and "Ashely".
32 dogs recorded (26 adults · 6 puppies).
Both eyes display purulent discharge in male English Bulldog "Tequila" DOB 5/7/16.
Yes. Inspectors recorded 24 problems across 27 visits. Each one is quoted in full above, in the inspector's own words.
At the most recent inspection on file, June 11, 2026, inspectors counted 39 dogs (21 adults · 18 puppies). The count is taken by the inspector on the day, so it moves with litters and sales.
The records name Boston Terrier, Bulldog, English Bulldog. Breeds come from the inspection paperwork, so a kennel may keep others that were never written down.
Kennels near this one, and others recording the same breeds.
| Kennel | Location | Why related | Dogs | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jonas Burkholder – Jonas & Roseann Burkholder | Rushville, NY | Nearby · 2 mi | 38 dogs | 5 notes |
| Eric Z & Regina Martin | Penn Yan, NY | Nearby · 4 mi | 25 dogs | No notes |
| Matthew Sensenig – Hidden Acres Kennels | Penn Yan, NY | Nearby · 4 mi | 18 dogs | 16 notes |
| Marvin M Hoover – Shady Lane Kennel | Penn Yan, NY | Nearby · 4 mi | 16 dogs | 8 notes |
| Elizabeth Williams – Blue Ribbon Puppies | Manorville, NY | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 23 dogs | 32 notes |
| Esle Yoder | Fort Plain, NY | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 61 dogs | 4 notes |
| Eli & Ellen Nolt | Saint Johnsville, NY | Same breed · Bulldog | 20 dogs | 2 notes |
| Heather Manaher – H & C's Dachshunds And Retrievers | West Valley, NY | Same breed · Bulldog | 41 dogs | 16 notes |
Showing 8 related kennelsView all 130 kennels in New York →
Share your firsthand experience getting a puppy from this breeder. Responses are anonymous, reviewed before publication, and kept separate from public inspection records.
This profile includes public USDA and Ohio inspection and licensing records. Notes describe conditions documented on the inspection dates shown.
If information is inaccurate or out of date, please let us know.
Submit a correctionWe collect and organize public records from government sources, including USDA APHIS and state departments of agriculture. We do not conduct our own inspections.
Learn how our data works →They summarize public licensing and inspection records from the agencies shown.
Records are updated as new public documents are collected and reviewed.
No. Pawthenticity organizes public records and does not provide endorsements.
Pawthenticity is reader supported. Your gift helps bring more public inspection records into the open, so people can make better-informed choices for dogs.
Support the database →