Breeder snapshot
Dog breeder in Plymouth, OH. 179 dogs at last count. USDA and Ohio inspectors cited 2 problems across 4 reports. Every report is free to read.
Plymouth, Ohio
Dog breeder in Plymouth, OH. 179 dogs at last count. USDA and Ohio inspectors cited 2 problems across 4 reports. Every report is free to read.
Matthew R Zimmerman – Plymouth, OH is linked to 4 public inspection reports, carrying 2 inspector findings, from February 2023 to April 2026.
Across 4 inspections between February 2023 and April 2026, inspectors recorded between 91 dogs and 179 dogs at Matthew R Zimmerman – Plymouth, OH. The most recent count was 179 dogs on April 22, 2026.
| Date | Licence | Type | Dogs counted | Inspector findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| February 28, 2023 | USDA 31-A-0968 | Inspection | 91 dogs | None |
| October 22, 2025 | Ohio CB0030XP | Routine inspection | 150 dogs | None |
| February 12, 2026 | USDA 31-A-0968 | Re-license inspection | 178 dogs | None |
| April 22, 2026 | USDA 31-A-0968 | Routine inspection | 179 dogs | 2 findings |
179 dogs recorded (99 adults · 80 puppies).
Surfaces in the primary enclosures of the whelping area have not been maintained to enable ready cleaning and sanitization. Roughly 18 of the 24 whelping boxes for mothers with litters have moderate chew damage. These areas have cracks and grooves that are not able to be cleaned and sanitized easily. Disease pathogens such as bacteria, viruses, or parasites can remain in these areas and cause illness in the dogs. All surfaces of the primary enclosures, including furniture, that are in contact with the dogs, must be maintained to be readily cleaned and sanitized. Correct by: 5/22/26
The primary enclosures have not been cleaned daily as required. Several days' worth of feces have accumulated on the outdoor portions of the sheltered housing facility. The licensee stated he does not currently spot clean these areas on a daily basis. Daily cleaning is required for proper husbandry and to control disease hazards, pests, and odors. Correct by removing excreta from primary enclosures daily, and from under raised floors as often as necessary to prevent excessive accumulations of feces and soiled dogs, disease hazards, pests, and odors. Correct by: 4/23/26
2 photographs taken by inspectors at Matthew R Zimmerman – Plymouth, OH and attached to their reports.

October 22, 2025 — Ohio inspection (report PDF)

October 22, 2025 — Ohio inspection (report PDF)
Yes. Inspectors recorded 2 problems across 4 visits. Each one is quoted in full above, in the inspector's own words.
At the most recent inspection on file, April 22, 2026, inspectors counted 179 dogs (99 adults · 80 puppies). The count is taken by the inspector on the day, so it moves with litters and sales.
The records name Boston Terrier, Maltese, Pomeranian, Pug, Shih Tzu. Breeds come from the inspection paperwork, so a kennel may keep others that were never written down.
Kennels near this one, and others recording the same breeds.
| Kennel | Location | Why related | Dogs | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| John R Garman | Plymouth, OH | Nearby · < 1 mi | 207 dogs | 11 notes |
| James R Garman | Plymouth, OH | Nearby · < 1 mi | 159 dogs | 6 notes |
| Harvey M Burkholder – H&A Kennel | Shiloh, OH | Nearby · 2 mi | 57 dogs | 2 notes |
| Isaac Z Martin | Shiloh, OH | Nearby · 3 mi | 25 dogs | 1 note |
| Abe R Yoder – Hollowside Puppies / Woodside Kennel / Treeline Kennel | Alexandria, OH | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 212 dogs | 10 notes |
| Alta Hostetler | Apple Creek, OH | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 34 dogs | No notes |
| Aden E Burkholder – Hickory Lane Kennel | Alexandria, OH | Same breed · Maltese | 28 dogs | No notes |
| Albert A Troyer | Fresno, OH | Same breed · Maltese | 19 dogs | 1 note |
| Andy H Raber | Walhonding, OH | Same breed · Pomeranian | 65 dogs | 2 notes |
| Barb Troyer | Walhonding, OH | Same breed · Pomeranian | 41 dogs | 10 notes |
| Andy Y Hostetler – Holmes Kennel | Holmesville, OH | Same breed · Pug | 47 dogs | No notes |
| David E Miller | Fresno, OH | Same breed · Pug | 129 dogs | 3 notes |
Showing 12 related kennelsView all 472 kennels in Ohio →
Share your firsthand experience getting a puppy from this breeder. Responses are anonymous, reviewed before publication, and kept separate from public inspection records.
This profile includes public USDA and Ohio inspection and licensing records. Notes describe conditions documented on the inspection dates shown.
If information is inaccurate or out of date, please let us know.
Submit a correctionWe collect and organize public records from government sources, including USDA APHIS and state departments of agriculture. We do not conduct our own inspections.
Learn how our data works →They summarize public licensing and inspection records from the agencies shown.
Records are updated as new public documents are collected and reviewed.
No. Pawthenticity organizes public records and does not provide endorsements.
Pawthenticity is reader supported. Your gift helps bring more public inspection records into the open, so people can make better-informed choices for dogs.
Support the database →