Breeder snapshot
Dog breeder in Plymouth, OH. 159 dogs at last count. USDA and Ohio inspectors cited 6 problems across 14 reports. Every report is free to read.
Plymouth, Ohio
Dog breeder in Plymouth, OH. 159 dogs at last count. USDA and Ohio inspectors cited 6 problems across 14 reports. Every report is free to read.
James R Garman – Plymouth, OH is linked to 14 public inspection reports, carrying 6 inspector findings, from June 2014 to August 2026.
Across 12 inspections between June 2014 and August 2026, inspectors recorded between 82 dogs and 159 dogs at James R Garman – Plymouth, OH. The most recent count was 159 dogs on August 26, 2026.
| Date | Licence | Type | Dogs counted | Inspector findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| June 4, 2014 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 90 dogs | None |
| November 17, 2015 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Attempted inspection | No access | None |
| December 17, 2015 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 91 dogs | 2 findings |
| December 22, 2015 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 91 dogs | None |
| February 15, 2017 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Attempted inspection | No access | None |
| May 16, 2017 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 82 dogs | 1 finding |
| September 12, 2018 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 86 dogs | None |
| March 17, 2020 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 106 dogs | None |
| March 16, 2022 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Re-license inspection | 150 dogs | None |
| June 10, 2024 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 149 dogs | None |
| December 20, 2024 | Ohio CB0005S4 | Routine inspection | 139 dogs | 1 finding |
| May 9, 2025 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Re-license inspection | 159 dogs | None |
| October 22, 2025 | Ohio CB0005S4 | Routine inspection | 137 dogs | 2 findings |
| August 26, 2026 | USDA 31-A-0458 | Routine inspection | 159 dogs | None |
91 dogs recorded (77 adults · 14 puppies).
Dog #0A01731050, white Maltese female, was noticed to be limping on her left rear leg. Upon further examination, the leg and paw were not sensitive to palpation. She had full range of motion with no signs of pain. There are no apparent outward signs to indicate the reason for the dog to be limping at today's inspection. Upon examination of the dogs' ears there is an excessive accumulation of red to brown crusty matter built up in both ears.
Dog #0A01717528, black and white Boston male, was noticed to have a large mass between his toes on his left front foot. In addition, there was a smaller mass located between his toes on his right front foot.
82 dogs recorded (61 adults · 21 puppies).
Dog with microchip #7E10022744 was noticed to be shaking it's head. Upon further examination, this dogs was noticed to have a heavy accumulation of red to brown matter built up in both ears. Ear issues can cause the animals pain and discomfort if they are left untreated. This dog must be seen by a licensed veterinarian. Documentation of examination, diagnosis and treatment must be made available for review by APHIS officials. Correct By: 5/23/2017
139 dogs recorded (110 adults · 29 puppies).
Upon inspection the licensee had two enclosures housing five adult dogs which had small areas of open metal flooring, during the inspection the licensee was able to correct this issue. Corrected on: 12/20/2024
137 dogs recorded (102 adults · 35 puppies).
A Havanese (microchip ending in 483) had a physical exam 1/7/25, whelped 3/21/25, and was rebred 7/28/25 before having a physical exam. This dog had a physical exam on 8/19/25.
A Yorkie (microchip ending in 0060 had a physical exam 1/7/25, whelped on 3/21/25, and was rebred 8/5/25 before having a physical exam. This dog had a physical exam on 8/19/25.
1 photograph taken by inspectors at James R Garman – Plymouth, OH and attached to their reports.

December 20, 2024 — Ohio inspection (report PDF)
Yes. Inspectors recorded 6 problems across 14 visits. Each one is quoted in full above, in the inspector's own words.
At the most recent inspection on file, August 26, 2026, inspectors counted 159 dogs (103 adults · 56 puppies). The count is taken by the inspector on the day, so it moves with litters and sales.
The records name Boston Terrier, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Havanese, Maltese, Mini Poodle, Yorkie. Breeds come from the inspection paperwork, so a kennel may keep others that were never written down.
Kennels near this one, and others recording the same breeds.
| Kennel | Location | Why related | Dogs | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew R Zimmerman | Plymouth, OH | Nearby · < 1 mi | 179 dogs | 2 notes |
| John R Garman | Plymouth, OH | Nearby · < 1 mi | 207 dogs | 11 notes |
| Harvey M Burkholder – H&A Kennel | Shiloh, OH | Nearby · 3 mi | 57 dogs | 2 notes |
| Isaac Z Martin | Shiloh, OH | Nearby · 3 mi | 25 dogs | 1 note |
| Abe R Yoder – Hollowside Puppies / Woodside Kennel / Treeline Kennel | Alexandria, OH | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 212 dogs | 10 notes |
| Alta Hostetler | Apple Creek, OH | Same breed · Boston Terrier | 34 dogs | No notes |
| Adora Puppies | Alexandria, OH | Same breed · Cavalier King Charles Spaniel | 410 dogs | No notes |
| Adrian Helmuth – Admar Canines | Sugarcreek, OH | Same breed · Cavalier King Charles Spaniel | 17 dogs | No notes |
| Aden E Burkholder – Hickory Lane Kennel | Alexandria, OH | Same breed · Havanese | 28 dogs | No notes |
| Allen & David Wengerd | Dundee, OH | Same breed · Havanese | 24 dogs | 3 notes |
| Albert A Troyer | Fresno, OH | Same breed · Maltese | 19 dogs | 1 note |
| Andy H Raber | Walhonding, OH | Same breed · Maltese | 65 dogs | 2 notes |
Showing 12 related kennelsView all 472 kennels in Ohio →
Share your firsthand experience getting a puppy from this breeder. Responses are anonymous, reviewed before publication, and kept separate from public inspection records.
This profile includes public USDA and Ohio inspection and licensing records. Notes describe conditions documented on the inspection dates shown.
If information is inaccurate or out of date, please let us know.
Submit a correctionWe collect and organize public records from government sources, including USDA APHIS and state departments of agriculture. We do not conduct our own inspections.
Learn how our data works →They summarize public licensing and inspection records from the agencies shown.
Records are updated as new public documents are collected and reviewed.
No. Pawthenticity organizes public records and does not provide endorsements.
Pawthenticity is reader supported. Your gift helps bring more public inspection records into the open, so people can make better-informed choices for dogs.
Support the database →